Roth vs Traditional IRA Calculator (US)

Roth vs Traditional IRA Calculator (US)

Emerging AI Skill PRO

Enter Calculation

The same pre-tax amount is set aside every year, at year end. Roth: taxed now, then grows tax-free. Traditional: invested in full, taxed when you withdraw.

Formula

FVRoth=C(1−tnow)·(1+r)n−1rFV_{\text{Roth}} = C\,(1-{{t_{\text{now}}}})\cdot \dfrac{(1+r)^{n}-1}{r}
Show calculation steps (2)
  1. Traditional IRA After-Tax Value

    FVTrad=C·(1+r)n−1r·(1−tretire)FV_{\text{Trad}} = C\cdot \dfrac{(1+r)^{n}-1}{r}\cdot(1-{{t_{\text{retire}}}})

    Invested in full, taxed at withdrawal at your retirement rate. r = Return Rate / 100, n = Years.

  2. After-Tax Difference (Roth − Traditional)

    Difference=C·(1+r)n−1r·(tretire−tnow)\text{Difference} = C\cdot \dfrac{(1+r)^{n}-1}{r}\cdot(t_{\text{retire}} - t_{\text{now}})

    Positive when the Roth keeps more; it is positive exactly when your retirement tax rate is higher than today's.

Usage stats

Advertisement

Results

Roth minus Traditional (after-tax)
$-11,335.29
USD
Traditional comes out ahead.
Roth IRA after-tax value $430,741.19
Traditional IRA after-tax value $442,076.48
Total contributed $180,000.00

Estimate only. Assumes a constant return and the same tax rates every year; not tax or investment advice.

Report an error on this page

Setting aside $6,000 of pre-tax income every year for 30 years at a 7% return, with a 24% tax rate today and 22% in retirement, leaves about $430,741 after tax in a Roth IRA and $442,076 in a traditional IRA. Traditional comes out $11,335 ahead because your tax rate falls in retirement.

How to use this Roth vs. traditional IRA calculator

Enter how much pre-tax income you set aside each year, your expected annual return, the years until retirement, your marginal tax rate today and the rate you expect when you withdraw. The calculator adds the contribution at the end of every year and shows what each account is worth after tax.

It compares the two accounts on an equal-cost basis: the same pre-tax dollars go in either way. With a Roth you pay tax now, so less money is invested, but withdrawals are tax-free. With a traditional IRA the full amount is invested and the withdrawals are taxed.

The formula

With a contribution C at the end of each year, return r and n years, both accounts grow by the same annuity factor A = ((1 + r)n − 1) / r (A = n when the return is 0).

  • Roth IRA after tax: C × (1 − tax rate now) × A
  • Traditional IRA after tax: C × A × (1 − tax rate in retirement)

So the account that wins is simply the one with the lower tax rate: Roth if you expect a higher rate in retirement, traditional if you expect a lower one. With the same rate both end equal.

Worked example

$6,000 a year, 7%, 30 years: A = (1.0730 − 1) / 0.07 ≈ 94.46. Roth: $6,000 × 0.76 × 94.46 ≈ $430,741. Traditional: $6,000 × 94.46 × 0.78 ≈ $442,076. Difference: −$11,335 (traditional ahead). If your rate is 12% now and 24% later, the Roth wins instead.

Advertisement

Frequently asked questions

Is a Roth IRA always better? No. On the same pre-tax budget a Roth comes out ahead only when your tax rate in retirement is higher than it is today. When your rate falls in retirement, a traditional IRA leaves more after tax.

What return should I use? Use a long-run estimate for your mix of investments and try a lower rate as a cautious case. The return does not change which account wins; it only scales both results.

Does this include IRA contribution limits? No, it uses the amount you enter. For 2026 the IRA contribution limit is $7,500, plus a $1,100 catch-up at age 50 or older ($8,600), under IRS Notice 2025-67. Your Roth limit can be lower if your income is in the phase-out range; check it with the Roth IRA calculator. The IRS has not yet published the 2027 limits (checked 9 November 2026).

Sources

Estimate only; not tax or investment advice.

Last updated:

Most popular in Financial

View all Financial calculators